Decisions · Field evidence

Reconstructing an outage from the evidence

At about 13:49 on 2 May 2026 circuit C1 tripped for a phase-S fault and reclosed. The lightning-location system had just recorded a −68.6 kA stroke near the line. The obvious answer is a backflashover. The burned horns, the silent arrester counters and the models say otherwise. This page follows the paper's reasoning: turn each observation into a test, run every candidate mechanism, and keep only what passes.

Step 1

What was recorded

Lightning-location strokes near T17–T22

TimePeakPosition
13:47:39−43 kAnorth of T19–T20, 0.79 km from T19
13:48:55−68.6 kA226 m NE of the line, a third of the span from T20
13:48:56−26.9 kA718 m SW of the line, near T21 (211 ms later)
13:50:43−18 kA0.26 km from T17, outside the span
13:52:13−43 kA0.77 km from T17, outside the span

Paper, Table V. The two highlighted strokes coincide with the fault.

What the inspection found, and what each finding demands

ObservationConstraint on a candidate
O1Burned C1-S horns at T20 and T21C1-S flashes at both towers
O2No other arcing in T16–T25; C2 unaffectedNo other path flashes
O3R and T counters unchanged at T20, T21No registered R/T arrester pulse
O4Single-phase fault, successful recloseA transient flashover with power-follow arc
O5Largest recorded strokes −68.6 and −26.9 kAA shield-wire stroke is not above the record; a weak stroke may be missing
Step 2

Test every candidate

Each row is computed now in your browser with the Backflashover Lab model (shield-wire strokes, 1.2/50 µs) or the Relief Wave Lab model (direct strokes on C1-S, 0.4/14 µs, θ = 300°), and with the span screening for the attachment limit. The paper's EMTP verdict is in the last column.

CandidateModel: paths that flashR/T arrestersO1O2Current plausible?HerePaper
running…

The backflashover model treats both circuits alike, so a phase-S flashover appears on C1 and C2 together; that alone violates O2. The direct-strike model has a single conductor and no R/T arresters, so O3 there rests on the paper's EMTP result (no R/T conduction up to 12.5 kA).

Step 3

Where and how strong could the stroke have been?

A direct stroke on C1-S matches only if it flashes both towers (O1) and is weak enough for its leader to reach phase S at that point (I ≤ Imax). Each cell is one simulation. Green cells satisfy both.

both towers flash, leader can reach Sboth flash, but I > Imax: the shield wire or ground would take itonly one tower or none flashesImax on the C1 side

Verdict

What the lightning record can and cannot say

  • Strokes of tens of kiloamperes are detected with high efficiency, so −68.6 kA bounds the current available for a backflashover.
  • Weak strokes are the ones most often missed, peak currents carry errors of about 13%, locations about 0.3 km, and about one flash in three reaches the ground at more than one point. An unrecorded 10 kA stroke is entirely possible.
  • Taking the largest nearby stroke as the cause would have pointed to backflashover, and so to better earthing or more R/T arresters. Neither protects phase S.
How the checks are made
O1: C1-S flashes at T20 and T21. O2: nothing else flashes (in the symmetric backflashover model a phase-S flashover counts on both circuits). Arresters: a pulse registers if it reaches 100 A and 2.3 mC. Current plausible: for shield-wire strokes, not above the recorded −68.6 kA (−96 kA is the paper's margin case); for direct strokes, I ≤ Imax on the C1 side at that point, from the surveyed terrain (Brown–Whitehead). Direct strikes "at a tower" are placed 2 m from it.

The paper's EMTP-RV model has eight frequency-dependent conductors, tower sections and both circuits; these teaching models are simpler, and their flashover times differ by a few tenths of a microsecond. The pattern of passes and fails is what matters.